Home

MPs call for smacking ban

MPs call for smacking banMPs call for smacking ban

Tuesday, 07, Oct 2008 12:00

Over 100 Labour MPs are calling for an amendment to the upcoming children and young persons bill which would ban parents from smacking their children.

The MPs have written to Gordon Brown calling for a free vote on the bill, although government sources indicate that is unlikely to happen.

Minister believe they have public support for the law's current status, whereby parents can chastise their child as long as they never inflict a mark or injury.

There is a chance some of the 111 MPs could rebel against the government and vote against the bill although parliamentary observers doubt it will come to that.

The letter reads: "This is clearly a conscience issue, equal to any others that have been granted such status. It should be debated and voted on freely, fairly and openly, in the parliamentary tradition.

"We are all Labour supporters and do not relish an unnecessary public battle with the government over a reform which we believe to be vital and long-overdue."

The issue of smacking last passed through parliament in 2004 when the government saw off a modest rebellion with Conservative support.


What do you think ?

Name 

Town/Country 

Your email 

Your comment 

Enter the text shown to the right

Your Views...

Unknown, England: Im not a parent but have been brought up by one and believe that children should have boundaries and need to know when they have overstepped them. i dont believe in harming children but how are we going to control them if we cant punish them? arent the new laws going to go hand in hand with everything bad that youngsters are getting upto nowadays and just going to contribute to a worse world to bring your children into? Parents need to be able to be parents, when my parents were growing up they got punished and theyre thankful for it because it has kept them on the right tracks but also made them the better people that they are today. I realise there are alot of bad people out there but new laws arent going to stop them from doing bad things.

S Williams, Buckinghamshire: Absolutely disgusting! Are we not mollycoddling our youngsters enough these days! Talk about a nanny state - when I was younger, if I did something wrong or dangerous, I got a smack. It taught me respect! The threat of getting caned by the headteacher taught me to behave myself at school! Look at youngsters now - you even look at a kid the wrong way and they threaten you, (most) kids have no respect for authority because parents, teachers, police, aren't allowed to discipline them - we need MORE discipline, not LESS!


New jobs channel

The new look politics.co.uk now includes a jobs channel, where you can search for jobs and sign up for our jobs bulletin.

Newsletter

Sign up to politics.co.uk’s daily newsletter and you’ll never miss a key political story again

Opinion Formers

Electoral Reform Society

The Electoral Reform Society is a voluntary organisation that campaigns for a better democracy, particularly through changes to our electoral system.

Public Affairs Jobs

Check out politics.co.uk's new jobs section, for government, public sector and public affairs roles

Current Vacancies:

Related News

Mandelson admits Blair persuaded him to return

It had been whispered since Friday following the shock announcement that Peter Mandelson had returned to the cabinet but finally the man himself admitted what many either knew already or believed to be true regardless of the facts.

Mr Blair persuaded Mandelson to return to cabinet

Related Analysis

The new Cabinet in full

The new Cabinet has now been fully revealed, after a weekend of gradual releases. Here it is, in full.

The new Cabinet in full

Latest Headlines

No warrant issued for Green search

Commons speaker Michael Martin has sparked outrage from MPs after admitting he was not told police planned to search shadow immigration minister Damian Green's parliamentary office.

Speaker Michael Martin said he was only officially told of Damian Green's arrest yesterday

Issue briefs

Labour Leadership

What is the Labour leadership? The Labour party leader heads the Parliamentary Labour Party (PLP) and is appointed as prime minister when the party holds a majority in the House of Commons.

Speakers Corner