politics.co.uk Logo

In Focus

Road pricing: A workable transport solution?

Wednesday, 16 May 2007 14:57

Road pricing: A workable transport solution?

Wednesday, 16 May 2007 14:57
Could road pricing curb growing congestion?
Road user pricing has proved to be one of the most controversial political topics of 2007, with 1.8 million British motorists signing a Downing Street petition opposing the scheme.

But, the number of cars on the roads continues to rise and the government expects congestion to increase 25 per cent over the next decade. Last year the Eddington Study warned congestion could cost the UK economy £22 billion by 2025.

Writing exclusively for politics.co.uk, ministers and opposition politicians explain how road pricing could be used to combat congestion. Transport secretary Douglas Alexander reassures motorists the government will not force through a national scheme, but is interested in the results of local studies. Shadow transport secretary Chris Grayling warns the government against imposing a road pricing scheme against public consensus, arguing motorists rightly fear it will become another 'stealth tax'. The Liberal Democrats transport spokesman Alistair Carmichael places road pricing in the wider context of climate change, but highlight's the possible implications for civil liberties. And Plaid Cymru transport spokesman Adam Price questions whether such a scheme could work in Wales, pointing out that the country lacks the public transport system necessary to underpin a successful road pricing scheme.

Responses 

  • Doing nothing is not an option

    The secretary of state for transport Douglas Alexander explains where the government stands so far on road pricing, ahead of local government pilot schemes. With congestion set to increase by 25 per cent by 2015, he warns doing nothing is not an option.More...
  • Government out of touch on road pricing scheme

    The shadow transport Chris Grayling argues the government is out of touch over the "pie in the sky" national road pricing scheme. He argues the 1.8 million people who signed an anti-road pricing petition were right to oppose an unrealistic scheme that should not be forced on local authorities.More...
  • Ignoring road pricing debate is irresponsible

    The Liberal Democrat transport spokesman Alistair Carmichael calls on drivers to ignore the "myths" surrounding road pricing. The facts include rising congestion and a rising threat to the economy and environment and maintain the status quo is no longer feasible.More...
  • Westminster must not impose road pricing on Wales

    Adam Price, Plaid Cymru parliamentary transport spokesperson, explains why Plaid support road pricing in principle, pointing to the success of congestion charging and small-scale road pricing schemes. But he questions whether a UK-wide scheme would meet Wales' unique transport needs.More...

Responses 

  • Motorists Voice

    The national road pricing proposals are nothing but a tax grab disguised unconvincingly as a green issue, and the British public knows it. More...
  • Road Haulage Association

    Road pricing is a distraction from the inescapable fact that we need a strategic roads programme and to invest more in infrastructure – as the government plans to do in both rail and air, where the need is less urgent.More...
  • North East Chamber of Commerce

    NECC hopes that the introduction of its new travel scheme will encourage staff at its member companies to travel by bus, train or Metro rather than car and therefore cut rush hour congestion.More...
  • Pacts

    The question for the Parliamentary Advisory Council on Transport Safety is whether road pricing would have a positive, negative or non-existent impact on safety on our roads.More...
  • Birmingham Chamber of Commerce

    So although road pricing may be the difficult option, we must consider the role it can play in reducing road congestion.More...